What
is a Master Limited Partnerships?
An MLP is business that is organized as a limited partnership and trades
proportionate shares of the partnership (units) on a public exchange.
What sort of businesses choose to be Master Limited Partnerships?
The typical business that chooses to be an MLP produces stable cash flow
in a resource related industry. Examples include hydrocarbon pipelines,
coal royalty owners, and certain real estate companies. There are also
MLPs involved in non-resource related businesses such as theme parks and
investment management. MLP units represent a share of real businesses
that have real assets and produce real cash flow.
Where are Master Limited Partnerships listed and traded?
The vast majority of MLP units are listed on the NYSE. The NYSE has more
restrictive listing requirements in terms of assets and earnings, than
other U.S. exchanges.
How can MLPs offer high returns?
1. Lower
cost of capital for stable cash flow assets. MLPs generally acquire
high cash flow, high depreciation assets (pipelines, terminals, platforms)
which produce relatively low accounting earnings. As a consequence of
the low GAAP earnings produced by the assets, traditional public companies
do not find the assets attractive. By collecting the high cash flow
assets together, the MLP is able to unlock the value in the assets.
The MLP investor focuses on the cash flow of the assets not on the accounting
earnings. Frequently a sale of a productive asset from an affiliated
c-corporation to a MLP is both accretive to the earnings of the seller,
and accretive to the cash flow of the acquirer.
2. Taxation. The partnership structure
avoids double taxation. In a traditional c-corporation, income is taxed
first at the corporate level, and any distributions to shareholders
are taxed again at the personal level. In a limited partnership, the
income is not taxed at the partnership level, but rather all profits
and losses are proportionally passed to the limited partners, and taxed
at the personal level.
In summary, MLPs have
a lower cost of capital for stable, high cash flow assets because their
investors are focused on cash flow, while traditional equity investors
are more focused on assets which grow accounting earnings. The limited
partnership structure also reduces the total taxes paid.
Why are MLP returns so high?
1. Lack
of institutional sponsorship. There is almost no institutional
investment in MLP units. The asset class is too small for many pension
funds, and as a consequence there are no specialty investment managers
involved. Mutual funds have historically avoided due to the complexity
of tax reporting. The potential for unrelated business income from the
underlying partnership makes MLP units potentially complicated for IRAs,
since sufficient unrelated business income could necessitate a tax filing
for the IRA. Smaller foundations and endowments have generally not invested
in MLP units due to the potential tax consequences. The main investor
segment that holds MLP units is high net worth individuals.
2. Complexity. MLP units are slightly more
complex to understand, and this likely presents a barrier to investment
for some high net worth individuals. Many investors are reluctant to
purchase a security that receives virtually no coverage in the financial
press, and does not fit neatly into the asset allocation mixes promoted
by Wall Street and the media – namely stocks, bonds, and cash.
Additionally, limited partners do not have the same rights as those
that stockholders typically exercise through their proxy vote (e.g.
election of directors, approval of auditors, etc.). Limited partnerships
usually do not have annual shareholder meetings.
3. Taxation. MLP unit holders receive a
K-1 from the partnership each year, and may also need to file tax returns
in each state where the LP has generated income. This increased level
of tax filing is sufficient to send many potential investors running.
Although the LP’s generally provide the tax benefit of a high
level of depreciation to allow most income to be deferred until sale,
the increase in filing is a further barrier to investment for the incremental
high net worth investor.
In summary, MLPs must
offer higher expected returns for the level of risk in order to attract
a limited pool of potential investors away from traditional asset classes. |